Anger at ‘shocking scenario’ projected by impact assessment on Sustainable Farming Scheme

Aled Jones

An impact assessment commissioned by Welsh Government examining the impact of its Sustainable Farming Scheme proposals forecasts a ‘shocking scenario’ for Welsh agriculture, according to NFU Cymru.

The recently published Potential economic effects of the Sustainable Farming Scheme Phase 4 Universal Actions Modelling Results research, carried out by ADAS, Pareto Consulting SRUC and University College Dublin, paints a bleak picture for Welsh farming.

Modelling predictions

The modelling, based on the potential economic effects of the previous 2022 outline proposals for the Sustainable Farming Scheme (SFS), predicts:

  • A 122,200 reduction in Welsh livestock units, in effect a 10.8% reduction in Welsh livestock numbers 
  • An 11% cut in labour on Welsh farms – the equivalent of losing 5,500 jobs based on current employment levels on Welsh farms
  • A £125.3m hit to output from the sector, and a loss of £199 million to farm business income (85%)

The data paints a ‘shocking scenario’ for Welsh farming and if this were to become a reality, one that completely contradicts the ‘Keep Farmers Farming’ title of Welsh Government’s latest consultation.
NFU Cymru

'Shocking scenario'

NFU Cymru said the data paints a ‘shocking scenario’ for Welsh farming and if this were to become a reality, one that completely contradicts the ‘Keep Farmers Farming’ title of Welsh Government’s latest consultation.

NFU Cymru President Aled Jones said: “Whilst this model makes a number of assumptions - including a projected 100% uptake of the scheme by Welsh farmers - these findings are, nevertheless, shocking to read. Even though this modelling relates to the 2022 proposals, given that the fundamental elements of the scheme have barely changed, the significant concerns held by the industry in relation to this impact assessment remain entirely valid.

Damaging consequences

“It is hugely concerning to read that Welsh Government’s own impact assessment illustrates such damaging consequences for the industry. There are also fundamental weaknesses within the report, not least that the wider impact on rural businesses and subsequent employment levels have not been modelled. As recently as July last year, Welsh Government announced record food and drink exports from Wales. Not even six months later and there are forecasts published that the core production base and producers behind this achievement will be significantly reduced. The Welsh food and drink sector is Wales’ largest employer and delivers multiple benefits for the Welsh environment, economy, communities and culture; it is a huge success story for this country. Our shared ambition should be to continue its growth, not undermine it.

“It is vital that as part of the latest consultation feedback from farmers and rural businesses are listened to. Many of the proposals that led to the damaging economic impact assessment are still contained in this latest consultation. NFU Cymru has long warned of the impacts of some of the proposals contained within the Sustainable Farming Scheme (SFS) scheme outline – not least the 10% tree planting and habitat requirements – on the sector’s productivity and viability. Welsh Government must listen and ensure fundamental changes to the shape of the scheme are made to avoid the damage the independent report highlights.

“This research only goes to further illustrate why there is such a high level of worry over the development of this policy. Welsh Government has said the universal actions will be achievable for all, however farmers continue to tell us that they will struggle to be productive and profitable if they join the scheme. Such a high and unacceptable level of reduction in on-farm labour, livestock numbers and farm business income, quite frankly, makes a mockery of Welsh Government naming this consultation ‘Keep Farmers Farming’. It is pure fallacy to suggest that these proposals are ‘Keeping Farmers Farming’ when the evidence published to date clearly shows that the SFS proposals will be so damaging for jobs and farming businesses in Wales.

NFU Cymru Council reaction

“NFU Cymru Council members were shocked upon being presented with these bleak figures last week. This data will send shockwaves through the industry and our wider rural communities.

“This research commissioned by Welsh Government themselves, that estimates the potential economic effects of elements of the proposed SFS, must act as a wakeup call. Welsh Government must urgently address those requirements associated with the proposed scheme, alongside the payment methodology, that this assessment has shown will have such a damaging impact on the future viability of Welsh farming and all those businesses who rely on a prosperous farming industry.”

Make your voice heard

The union added that the ‘shocking’ assessment provided further evidence that everyone associated with Welsh agriculture must make their voice heard during the consultation period.

Welsh Government’s Sustainable Farming Scheme ‘Keep Farmers Farming’ consultation closes on Thursday 7 March. Please visit our hub for further details about the proposals, there will also be a consultation support tool to assist farmers in producing their individual responses.

Ask us a question about this page

Once you have submitted your query someone from NFU Cymru will contact you. If needed, your query will then be passed to the appropriate NFU policy team.

You have 0 characters remaining.

By completing the form with your details on this page, you are agreeing to have this information sent to the NFU for the purposes of contacting you regarding your enquiry. Please take time to read the NFU’s Privacy Policy if you require further information.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.