Consultation proposals do not match Welsh farmers' ambitions for growth'

31 October 2018

‘Welsh farmers have a vision for continued growth of the food and farming sector in Wales but are concerned that the  Welsh Government’s ‘Brexit and Our Land’ consultation proposals do not match that ambition’, according to NFU Cymru in the Union’s formal consultation response.

  • Union states that food production should be at the heart of new policy
  • Concern at lack of stability measure in Welsh Government proposals
  • Farmers should be properly rewarded for the Public Goods that they already deliver for society

Following an extensive consultation engagement programme, with an ‘unprecedented’ level of response from its members across Wales, the lack of acknowledgement of the importance of food production in the proposals has emerged as a significant concern for the Union and its members.

NFU Cymru President John Davies said: “Frustratingly, the proposals contained within the ‘Brexit and Our Land’ consultation do not match the ambition of Welsh farmers who want to play their part in supplying safe, quality, fully traceable food that will underpin further  growth of  an industry currently worth £6.9 billion to the Welsh economy.

“This omission is extremely surprising when you consider that the Welsh food and drink sector is one of Wales’ four foundation sectors in ‘Prosperity for All – The Economic Action Plan for Wales’ - a national strategy published by Welsh Government only last year to help deliver its priorities for the Assembly term.

“This can be corrected, and an opportunity exists for Welsh Government to work with the sector from farm to fork to put in place a sustainable, and fully integrated, Welsh food and farming policy. Welsh Government should bring together the work on the new Food and Drink Action Plan and future farming policy to drive towards new bold and ambitious targets to grow our share of produce sold in the UK retail and food service sectors, expand our reach in export markets, and increase the amount of Welsh food procured by the public sector.

“Food production and the environment must go hand in hand; future policy should underpin the continued production of world leading food from Wales at the same time as recognising and rewarding farmers for the full range of public goods that they deliver for society. Getting this right will be crucial to the development of ‘Brand Wales’, a brand to market and promote Wales as a country of high quality food and drink produced in diverse and beautiful landscapes around a strong natural asset base, on the world stage.”

As part of its response to the Welsh Government document, NFU Cymru has also highlighted its significant fears that, unlike many other countries across the world, the ‘Brexit and Our Land’ proposals do not contain measures to protect Welsh farming businesses against the volatility and instability that the industry has experienced in recent years. These fears, the Union says, are only increased by the uncertainty that the UK’s departure from the European Union will bring.

“During our consultation engagement programme, our membership has reaffirmed the NFU Cymru policy of a future sustainable agriculture programme built around three cornerstones of productivity, environment and stability. All three combine to give a truly integrated and comprehensive programme that will deliver economically, environmentally, socially and culturally for Wales.” explained NFU Cymru President John Davies.

“Without stability the industry cannot deliver the outcomes that the Welsh public associates with the sector. Vibrant farm businesses underpin the delivery of a broad range of goods and services for Wales.  This starts with the production of safe, high quality, traceable, affordable food and includes maintaining our iconic Welsh landscapes, enhancing the quality of our environment, supporting tourism, and underpinning the vitality of our rural communities and the Welsh language.

 “We are also concerned that thorough impact assessments have not been carried out into the long-term impact of the withdrawal of support payments for active food producing family farms, and the knock-on effect this will have on rural communities in Wales.

“Fundamentally, NFU Cymru does not support the phasing out of current schemes until there is clear evidence that replacement policies can deliver at least the same level of stability for farming businesses, the food supply chain and rural communities that current policies provide.”

NFU Cymru President John Davies said the strength of feeling over the plans contained within the ‘Brexit and Our Land’ consultation underlined the need for Welsh Government to work with the industry, to deliver a policy that will deliver for the people and communities of Wales.

“Every farmer we spoke to was proud to be a farmer, proud to produce food for the consumer, proud to be an integral part of their community, proud to care for their environment and proud to be running a successful and diverse business,” said Mr Davies. “Not one member identified themselves solely as a ‘land manager’ – many took offence at this narrow definition being used by Welsh Government in this consultation.  

“It fills me with immense pride that such a large proportion of our membership has submitted their views as part of this process. The level of engagement of our membership in events arranged by NFU Cymru and the volume of consultation responses from the Welsh agricultural industry shows the strength of feeling over these proposals.

“Welsh Government will be judged on how they incorporate all these views into the development of new policies and schemes.

“For our part we want to work with Welsh Government in genuine partnership to help design and implement policies that deliver our vision and ambition for sustainable growth of the food and farming industry in Wales.”

NFU Cymru's rural business and community networking day on the 29th October:


Ask us a question about this page

Once you have submitted your query someone from NFU Cymru will contact you. If needed, your query will then be passed to the appropriate NFU policy team.

You have 0 characters remaining.

By completing the form with your details on this page, you are agreeing to have this information sent to the NFU for the purposes of contacting you regarding your enquiry. Please take time to read the NFU’s Privacy Policy if you require further information.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.